Reflecting on the First Year: Why We Do What We Do

In two weeks, I will be done with my first year in medical school! My last class was on Friday, and my last clinic shift was last Tuesday. The next couple of weeks consist only of three exams, so I will probably take several opportunities to break from studying and write reflections on this past year. Today is a particularly good day for that for me: it’s Mother’s Day, and my mom is the person who played the most significant role in inspiring me to pursue medicine as my means through which to change the world for the better.

At the beginning of the year, our Chief of Medicine welcomed us and spoke to us about perfection. He posed and answered four questions: “What is it (perfection) made from? What is its form or essence? What produced it? For what purpose do we pursue perfection?

In response to the last question, he told the following story (which I will try to recreate as best as I can):

On Tuesday I had the morning off, and I did what most New Orleans people do… I went to a coffee shop. (laugh) So I was sitting down, sipping my drink, and I saw this couple waiting in line – well, they weren’t a couple… yet. They were standing about two people apart, and the man was ahead in line, chatting with the woman. It was clear that they were hitting it off. The guy was stalling at the register as he was being asked what type of milk he wanted. Same milk as he had yesterday! (laugh) But no, he was delaying, trying to make his drink as complicated as possible so as to keep talking with the lady, and eventually when his drink was done, he stood there like this… “So… would you like to go out sometime? I mean, only if you want to, no pressure or anything..” (laugh) “Sure, sure, that would be nice to go out.” Now, of course, my memory might be a bit off, and she might have asked him out, I guess that happens too nowadays, but the important thing is that they met, and I imagined what he would’ve been like on Tuesday night, sitting by the phone, doing the whole dialing up until the last number and then hanging up deal. But eventually the feeling would overwhelm him and his wondering whether it’s too soon, and then he calls, “Hey” “Hey” “How’s it going?” “Good” “So, do you still want to go out?” “Yeah, sure.” “When’s good for you?” “Friday is good.” “Dinner?” “Sure” “What would you like to eat?” “Oh anything’s fine by me, you?” “Same, anything’s good…” (laugh) “Hmm” “Let’s see… how about Chinese?” (laugh) “Sure, that’d be great” “Great” And so on, and then tonight they’ll be going out to dinner and it’ll be the beginning of a beautiful relationship. They’ll make small talk, talk about their favorite music and books and what they like to do, and they’ll hit it off again, and later that night he’ll be dropping her off and there’ll be that moment for the good night kiss… (laugh, some noise from the audience) Keep it clean, kids… anyways, a good night kiss, and he’ll be driving away, and he’ll be thinking to himself: (arms outstretched) Nothing can be better than this! And everything in his world is great and makes sense, and he’ll be driving home, and at the very moment, a single cell in his body will snap, and that’ll be all it takes – that’ll be the start of his lymphoma, and five years later – it takes that long for it to be detectable – five years later he’ll be coming in for his checkup and you’ll be just done your internship. Will you be the one to tell him the bad news, the one to find the lump and walk him through what needs to be done? Yes, you will, and five years later he’ll walk right back in that clinic, this time with his wife and his kids, and you’ll say to him, “You’ve made it through the window. It’s statistically almost impossible for the lymphoma to come back now. Go live your life with your wife and kids, and do all the great things you want to do.” And he’ll take his wife and kids in his arms, and he’ll think to himself: Nothing can be better than this. And it’ll all be because of you – because you were there to catch that lymphoma and beat the disease. And hey, it starts now: somewhere, there is someone in this exact same situation, and the exact same consequences will happen five years from now. Will you be there to catch the disease and beat it? It’s a race between you and the disease, and that race begins right now.

When I first heard that story, I wrote this:

“I’m probably not doing it justice, but you might see how such a simple story can be meaningful for a student going into medicine. He mentioned that one of the tragedies of medical education that he discussed with his peers is when students enter aspiring to do all manner of good and leave just wanting to do well. I think it’s important for young physicians to keep a good perspective about what we’re doing. As important as it is to be humble (i.e. not develop a God-complex) and realize our limitations (i.e. that much of medicine is the patient’s decision and responsibility, even if they hold physicians accountable for it, justly or unjustly), I also think it’s important that we know how much we can do for patients and how big a difference we are making.

A year later, I still feel the same way, despite having learned a great deal about the problems of health care through reading and contextualizing, having experienced some of the frustrations and obstacles that physicians face as they try to provide great medical and personal care for their patients, and having waded knee-deep through the burnt remains of the New Orleans health care system. Where others may see insurmountable barriers and despair, I see room for improvement and the greatest challenge of our lives. I realize now how much variance there is in the experiences of physicians across disciplines and practice settings (and even great variance in the learning experiences of medical students in the same class at the same medical school): accordingly, I understand now how little use there is in criticizing the way people feel, even if those feelings are tainted with frustration and are seemingly insensitive. I think a lot of the doctors who express the most frustration and bitterness about the current state of health care are those who have to deal with the full brunt of this system’s failures. With that in mind, I’m very grateful for the education I’ve received thus far at my medical school: I’ve had a chance to see a health care delivery system at its worst, in its most dilapidated state, and also see the good people who remain shed sweat, blood, and tears as they struggle to pull the pieces back together. Some are bitter, angry, and hardened in a way that most people will never be, and yet they hold on to their convictions and commitments for as long as they can bear it. Others are more optimistic, hopeful, and eager to get beyond the pitfalls and the problems. I tend more towards the latter, but without understanding the former (and experiencing it), anything I say about health care in general, any dreams and reforms I might pursue, would have little meaning.

Keeping all of these experiences and feelings in my memory, I look forward to each day that I develop a little more into the physician and leader I want to

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: